Court Orders Disclosure of Documents That May Evidence Fraud on Chinese Court

A plaintiff commenced an action in British Columbia seeking to enforce a default judgment obtained in China. The Chinese lawsuit came about because of a commercial dispute between a Chinese manufacturer of construction machinery, the plaintiff, and a Chinese distributor. It was alleged that the owners of the Chinese distributor, who reside in Canada, had personally guaranteed the debts of the Chinese distributor. This allegation was not opposed by the defendants in the British Columbia enforcement action.

 

In defence to the enforcement action, the Defendants plead that the Chinese default judgment was obtained fraudulently because: 1) the defendants were not served in accordance with Chinese rules; and 2) certain material documents were not disclosed to the Chinese court.

The defendants brought a motion for the production of documents, some of which the plaintiff admitted did exist and were not disclosed to the Chinese court. Despite these admissions, the plaintiff opposed the defendants’ motion. The court found that “it remain[ed] an issue whether the failure to inform the Intermediate Peoples Court of Longyn, Fujian Province, China of the existence of the [documents] represents a fraud on that court.” Accordingly, the British Columbia court ordered the production of various documents but refused to order the production of others.

Read the Lonking (China) Machinery Sales Co. Ltd. v Zhao, 2017 BCSC 2154 case here.

Ruzbeh Hosseini is an associate who practices in the business litigation and cross-border litigation groups. Ruzbeh is regularly involved in the development of litigation strategy and he has appeared in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and Ontario Court of Appeal on behalf of clients.

Cross-Border Litigation Services

Cambridge LLP offers comprehensive Cross-Border Litigation and arbitration services in Canada, including:

  • Enforcement of Foreign  Judgements/Arbitral Awards
  • Debt Recovery Litigation
  • Shareholder Disputes
  • Partnership Dispute
  • Oppression Remedy Cases
  • Anton Piller Orders
  • Mareva Injunctions
  • Letters Rogatory/Letters of Request
  • Forum Non-Conveniens Motions
  • Jurisdictional Disputes
  • Anti-Suit Injunctions
  • Franchise Disputes
  • Franchise and Licensing
  • International Arbitration
  • Civil Fraud
  • Asset Recovery and Tracing
  • Protection of Citizens Detained/arrested in foreign Countries
    (Consular Duties and related Representation)

Join our Cross-Border Litigation Bulletin

Please take a moment to sign up for our Cross-Border Litigation e-bulletin. We'll keep you up to date on key developments in the law and firm updates.

Invalid email address